Follow the painted piano keys across the street from the theatre and you will find yourself at a wonderful breakfast and lunch restaurant, Toast Coffeehouse. The art gallery hallway welcomes you as you walk past, of all things, an electric chair! As you enter the restaurant the decor changes to a mix of art world meets industrial park/steampunk. The greeters take your number and call you as there is usually a wait. The good thing is they use the Nowait app so you can "get in line"on the app as long as you are within ten miles of the restaurant.
![]() |
Art Gallery Entry and Electric chair on the right. |
Belgian Gluten Free Waffle with Berries and Turkey Bacon |
fresh strawberries!
Watermelon & Feta Salad |
I should, of course, mention their coffee, which is a breakfast blend. It is very good and stands on it's own for a breakfast coffee. I usually find these roasts to be weak, but not this one. I have enjoyed it hot, iced and cappuccino and have enjoyed each. Toast also carries an array of delicious muffins if you are looking for something on the lighter side.
Last time we were at Toast, I ordered the seasonal special salad pictured above. It consisted of fresh watermelon, red onions, feta cheese, mixed greens, and topped off with their wonderful Raspberry Champagne dressing! It was tangy and sweet all at once. It was refreshing and satisfying. I highly recommend this salad.
The waitstaff and busboys have been some of the friendliest and most accommodating servers I have encountered. Because my son has to have gluten free pancakes, waffles, and french toast, they have gone out of their way to tell us exactly what kind they serve when he has enjoyed his meal. Both my son and I have to have sugar free syrup and they have made a point of serving that separately and informing us of a special brand they carry. My son also cannot have milk or sweetened almond milk. The waitress was kind enough to bring him coconut milk right from the can for his coffee! I cannot recommend Toast Coffeehouse enough, not just for the incredible food but for the service as well. Patchogue is their second location. The original is in Port Jefferson. Toast has certainly become my favorite place to have breakfast!